CITY OF SAN ANTONIO
Request for Council Action

Agenda Item # 4
Council Meeting Date: 12/13/2007
RFCA Tracking No: R-2621 


DEPARTMENT:  Animal Care Services

DEPARTMENT HEAD:  Jeffrey Hale

 
COUNCIL DISTRICT(S) IMPACTED:
City Wide
 
SUBJECT:
Proposed Revisions to Chapter 5

SUMMARY:

An ordinance amending Chapter 5 of the City Code.

Objective 4.1 in the Animal Care Strategic Plan outlines the steps to update Chapter 5 of the City Code dealing with animals to ensure it is congruent with best practices and supporting of achieving a “no kill” goal by 2012. Specifically, Chapter 5 deals with general animal regulations, animal cruelty, the Animal Care Advisory Board, livestock, dangerous animals, rabies, licensing and animal nuisances.  

 

On October 17, 2007, the Animal Care Services Advisory Board presented their proposed recommendations to Chapter 5 of the City Code.  At that time, the City Council referred this item to the Quality of Life Committee for further discussion.  During the Quality of Life Committee meeting of November 20, 2007, Animal Care Services staff  focused their briefing to the Committee on new proposed language relating to dangerous and vicious animals. The Quality of Life Committee approved the new proposed language and has referred the item to the full City Council for consideration.


 

BACKGROUND INFORMATION:

On September 14, 2006 City Council approved a resolution supporting the implementation of a community wide five-year Animal Care Strategic Plan that would challenge and lead the community to achieve a “no kill” goal by 2012. 

 

Achieving a “no kill” goal by 2012 requires increasing the entire community’s awareness of the critical animal care issues that the City of San Antonio faces.  More importantly, it also requires increasing the level of responsibility that pet owners take for the care and treatment of their animals.   In January 2007, an Ad Hoc Subcommittee was appointed by the Board to review and make recommendations to revise Chapter 5 of the City Code.

 

From February through June 2007, the Subcommittee conducted a series of meetings to discuss proposed revisions. The Subcommittee presented their recommendations to the Board on July 11, 2007. At that time, the Board made the decision to hold a stakeholder meeting on August 1, 2007 and a community input meeting on August 22, 2007 regarding the proposed revisions to Chapter 5.

 

The Ad Hoc Subcommittee consisted of both Board and non-board members. Board members included Mary Abbott (District 7), Ellen Lockwood (District 8), Laura McKieran (District 1) and Pat DiGiovanni (ex-officio). Non-Board members included Mary Beth Duerler (Responsible Pet Owners Alliance), Joel Hailey (Voice for Animals), Michelle Molina (Stray Cat Adoptions of Texas), City staff from Animal Care Services, City Attorney’s Office, Health and Housing & Neighborhood Services.

 

In addition to the attached draft of the Chapter 5 Ordinance (Attachment A), the new proposed fee schedule amending the current fees (Attachment B) is also attached. Because community education of the Ordinance is imperative to knowledge of and compliance with the new provisions, it is recommended that implementation of the sections relating to the intact dog permit and sterilization of impounded animals (sections 5-107 and 5-156) be delayed until January 1, 2009. The provisions relating to dangerous animals (Article IV) are recommended to become effective immediately. Also, it recommended that sections 5-108, 5-109, 5-111, 5-112, 5-113, 5-114, 5-115 and 5-151 become effective March 1, 2008. All other sections would become effective January 1, 2008.


 

ISSUE:

To encourage responsible pet ownership, Chapter 5 of the City Code must be updated.


 

ALTERNATIVES:
City Council can accept the Board proposal, recommend adjustments to the revisions, reject the revisions or request time for additional study and review of the proposal.
 
FISCAL IMPACT:

Originally, ACS proposed free licensing for all residents using micro chips as the primary means of licensing. The fiscal impact of this was not addressed in the FY ’08 budget that was presented to Council. To address this fiscal impact, ACS is now proposing to charge a nominal fee of $7.00 per chip to cover the cost of the micro chip and the staff time required to implant the chip. ACS may also provide the citizens of San Antonio free low cost clinics on a quarterly basis where the micro chip service can be obtained free of charge for their pet (s). If budget allows, ACS will propose free micro chipping as an enhancement in the budget for the 2009 fiscal year. Regardless of the demand, the $7.00 fee will allow ACS  to provide this service and still cover the costs associated with providing the service.

 

Since Animal Care Services will be offering free licensing, there will be a loss of licensing revenue that was originally projected to be $207,132. The total pet owners estimated to take advantage of the free licensing is 30,000, which has factored a modest increase for demand. At the Free Quarterly Clinics, ACS anticipates a total of 1,000 citizens to take advantage of the free micro chipping service. The financial impact of this proposed action is estimated to be $5,000 annually. Although this amount was not budgeted in the Animal Care budget, grants and other funding opportunities may be pursued to cover the estimated budget impact. Should grants not be available, Animal Care will not be able to provide the free clinics listed due to budgetary constraints. The $5,000 total includes an expense of $5.00 per microchip and the 1,000 estimated pet owners who may take advantage of the free micro chipping. The total fiscal impact is estimated to be $212,132.

 

The requirement to obtain the free licensing is that pet owners must show proof of current rabies vaccination. According to the August 2007 survey completed by the San Antonio Area Foundation, only 40% of pet owners are current with their vaccinations. To help offset the total fiscal impact listed above, ACS will be charging $12.00 for the rabies vaccination to those pet owners who are not current and would like to license their pets for free. That would mean that approximately 18,000 pet owners (60% of 30,000) would need to have their pets vaccinated for rabies. The amount of revenue generated by this effort is estimated to be $216,000.

 

Taking all of the above into consideration, it is anticipated that the final budgetary impact will be neutral.


 
RECOMMENDATION:

Staff recommends that the proposed revisions to Chapter 5 be approved, including the proposed fee schedule.


 
ATTACHMENT(S):

File DescriptionFile Name
Proposed Chapter 5 Ordinance Attachment A.pdf
Proposed Fee Schedule AC Amendment B.doc
Voting Results  
Ordinance/Supplemental Documents 200712131291.pdf


DEPARTMENT HEAD AUTHORIZATIONS:
 Jeffrey L. Hale   Director   Animal Care Services

APPROVED FOR COUNCIL CONSIDERATION:
 T.C. Broadnax   Assistant City Manager    
 Pat DiGiovanni   Deputy City Manager